Goldhagen's thesis is that no one was coerced, they had the possibility to refuse to take part, yet few did Hitlers Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust by Daniel Jonah Goldhagen is a richly detailed and provocative history of the Holocaust. [62] On 11 April 1935, Goerdeler ordered the end of Haake's boycott, and provided a list of "non-Aryan" physicians permitted to operate under the existing laws and those who were excluded. Quite a radical departure from the "I was only obeying orders" school of thought. I learned that since the 1800s Germans had been blaming the Jewish people for the problems of their country and that this blame became even stronger after World War I. Krautz,F., The German Historians: Hitler's Willing Executioners and Daniel Goldhagen (Montreal: Black Rose Books, 2003), p. 2 Summary In this essay, the author Analyzes the historiography of the 'ordinary germans' during the third reich years and the legacy of goldhagen controversy. Since 1933, the Nazi-controlled government continued their barrage of propaganda by holding mass rallies and speeches, along with other strategies to rally support for Lebensraum , war and anti-semitic campaigns. [82] The phrase ein Volk von Dmonen (translated "a people/nation of demons") was often used by the Nazis to describe Jews, and the title of the cover story was meant by Rudolf Augstein and the editors of Der Spiegel to suggest a moral equivalence between the Nazi view of Jews and Goldhagen's view of Germans. Goldhagen himself mentions that a large proportion of the Jewish upper classes in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century. Brownings book is much easier to read for the lay person of Holocaust studies. [81], When the English edition of Hitler's Willing Executioners was published in March 1996, numerous German reviews ensued. In May 1996, Goldhagen was interviewed about Hitler's Willing Executioners by the American journalist Ron Rosenbaum. I didn't manage to finish this. Browning argued that the men of Unit 101 agreed willingly to participate in massacres out of a basic obedience to authority and peer pressure, not blood-lust or primal hatred.[7]. That its erroneous to believe the Nazis were capable of brainwashing an entire nation that wasn't already predisposed to embrace a hatred of Jews. Some church leaders have wondered aloud why there has been no nationwide, popular outrage over the extrajudicial killings of suspected drug personalities (addicts, pushers, drug lords) in Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's so-called "War on Drugs.". It still does. [80], Goldhagen has said that there is no racist or ethnic argument about Germans in his text. Some historians have characterized its reception as an extension of the Historikerstreit, the German historiographical debate of the 1980s that sought to explain Nazi history. Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust. Hitler's Willing Executioners provides conclusive evidence that the extermination of European Jewry engaged the energies and enthusiasm of tens of thousands of ordinary Germans. Goldhagen's book was treated as a way of ensuring that Germany came to terms with its past. In this book we learn that not only did the average German know the full details of the Holocaust and General Plan OST (despite both being highly classified), but supported these measures with glee. Some of the outright falsehoods include: that little is new in the book; that it puts forward a monocausal and deterministic explanation of the Holocaust, holding it to have been the inevitable outcome of German history; that its argument is ahistorical; and that it makes an "essentialist," "racist" or ethnic argument about Germans. At most Goldhagen provides an explanation as to why people do the things they do regardless of their social or economic background. So, yes the author makes some important points in helping us to understand the incomprehensible but he does tend to make the same point over and over again and with increasing vehemence, like a man bringing his fist down continually on his desk. Please try again later. Hitler's Willing Executioners was dismissed as fundamentally ahistorical in Commentary, of all places, and as a "bizarre inversion of the Nazi view of the Jews as an insidious, inherently. Hitler's Willing Executioners is an extraordinary and original contribution to the mountain of literature on the Holocaust. Goldhagen wants to make the question simply whether the Germans were willing participants or not, and he argues they were. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen is the author of #1 international bestseller Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust (Vintage, 1997), published in fifteen languages, which. To redeem, copy and paste the code during the checkout process. Goldhagen takes a very different view of Germans, Nazi or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen is a controversial American author and former associate professor of political science and social studies at Harvard University. It was. I think not. petrators, who made willing choices.5 In comparison with other explanations of the Holocaust, Goldhagen's argument combines aspects of the older intentionalist school, which argues that it was Hitler's plan all along to murder the Jews, with what Omer Bartov calls the "common sense" school, especially influential among orthodox Jews. This is where youll see your current point status and your earned rewards. It has no nationality. Hitler s Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust By Daniel Jonah Goldhagen Alfred A. Knopf, 1996, 601 pp. Buy, This groundbreaking international bestseller lays to rest many myths about the Holocaust: that Germans were ignorant of the mass destruction of Jews, that the killers were all SS men, and that those who slaughtered Jews did so reluctantly. [53] Bauer wrote of the main parties of the Weimar Coalition that dominated German politics until 1930, the leftist SPD and the liberal DDP were opposed to anti-Semitism while the right-of-the-centre Catholic Zentrum was "moderately" antisemitic. [12], Goldhagen charged that every other book written on the Holocaust was flawed by the fact that historians had treated Germans in the Third Reich as "more or less like us," wrongly believing that "their sensibilities had remotely approximated our own. They were not automatons blindly following orders, rather their particular brand of Jew hatred made them willing exterminators of people who had no power. 'Perpetrators and Victims: The Goldhagen Debate and Beyond", in LaCapra, D. Shandley, Robert & Riemer, Jeremiah (eds. THIS is Hannah Arendt's "banality of evil." [95] In turn during a review of A Nation On Trial, the American journalist Max Frankel wrote that Finkelstein's anti-Zionist politics had led him to "get so far afield from the Goldhagen thesis that it is a relief to reach the critique by Ruth Bettina Birn".[96]. By Clive James. Had there not been a depression in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis wouldn't have come to power. Buy, Dec 18, 2007 [59], The Israeli historian Omer Bartov wrote that to accept Goldhagen's thesis would also have to mean accepting that the entire German Jewish community was "downright stupid" from the mid-19th century onwards because it is otherwise impossible to explain why they chose to remain in Germany, if the people were so murderously hostile or why so many German Jews wanted to assimilate into an "eliminationist anti-Semitic" culture. Goldhagen had already indicated his opposition to Browning's thesis in a review of Ordinary Men in the July 13, 1992, edition of The New Republic titled "The Evil of Banality". Author goes to Berlin to debate Holocaust, Forum on Holocaust canceled after an author withdraws, Holocaust writer in storm over role of Catholic Church, "Goldhagen Wins German Prize For Holocaust Book", "Daniel Jonah Goldhagen's 'Crazy' Thesis: A Critique of Hitler's Willing Executioners", "Motives, Causes, and Alibis: A Reply to My Critics", "Why Obama Might Save Israel From Nuclear Iran", "'Hitler's Willing Executioners': An Exchange,", "Goldhagen - His Critics and His Contribution", "Goldhagen in Germany: Historians' Nightmare & Popular Hero. This book makes a powerful argument. Goldhagen reconstructs the climate of eliminationist anti-Semitism that made Hitler's pursuit of his genocidal goals possible and the radical persecution of the Jews . I read this years ago and was shocked at the implications of the author's premise, although not unwilling to accept it. Traditional explorations tended to accept at face value the usual defenses offered by the Germans: Either they did not . Goldhagen doesn't separate the religious anti-Semitism of Martin Luther with the racial anti-Semitism of the 1800s and later the Nazis. It stifled protests by conservatives against persecutions of the Jews, as well as Hitler's proclamation of a "racial annihilation war" against the Soviet Union. Whatever its weaknesses as causal model, it is first-rate history that has transformed the way we look at the Holocaust. [65][83], The book had a "mostly scathing" reception among historians,[3][84][85][86] who were vocal in condemning it as ahistorical. "[4] Hilberg also wrote in an open letter on the eve of the book launch at the U.S. [19] The British historian Sir Ian Kershaw, a leading expert in the social history of the Third Reich, wrote, "The road to Auschwitz was built by hate, but paved with indifference,"[20][21] that is, that the progress leading up to Auschwitz was motivated by a vicious form of antisemitism on the part of the Nazi elite, but that it took place in a context where the majority of German public opinion was indifferent to what was happening. Kwiet, Konrad: "'Hitler's Willing Executioners' and Ordinary Germans': Some Comments on Goldhagen's Ideas". [22] Goldhagen, in contrast, declared the term "indifference" to be unacceptable, contending that the vast majority of Germans were active antisemites who wanted to kill Jews in the most "pitiless" and "callous" manner possible. "Revising the Holocaust" (1997) pp.199-200, 209. [51] Browning was echoing the conclusions of the German conservative historian Andreas Hillgruber who once presented at a historians' conference in 1984 a counter-factual scenario whereby, had it been a coalition of the German National People's Party and Der Stahlhelm that took power in 1933 without the NSDAP, all the antisemitic laws in Germany that were passed between 1933 and 1938 would still have occurred but there would have been no Holocaust. What made Germany unique was the level of organization and planning that went into this genocide. Get help and learn more about the design. Goldhagen's theory has created a firestorm when it came out, but he's extremely convincing and his view of Nazi Germany is as sad as it's terrifying. [91] Rosenbaum asked "So you would agree with Himmelfarb's argument? To the Editors. Introduction On April 8th, 1996, the United States Holocaust Research Institute hosted an evening of dialogue to examine the issues raised by Daniel Goldhagen's deliberately provocative book, Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, in which the author seeks to challenge the canons of Holocaust scholarship and to directly confront its acknowledged masters. Reviewed by Stanley Hoffmann May/June 1996 Published on May 1, 1996 A challenging, powerfully argued, and morally passionate account of the extermination of the Jews by Nazi Germany. When they started invading other nations, they would kill or imprison every Jew they found men, women and children. By clicking Sign Up, I acknowledge that I have read and agree to Penguin Random House's Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and understand that Penguin Random House collects certain categories of personal information for the purposes listed in that policy, discloses, sells, or shares certain personal information and retains personal information in accordance with the policy. This is the problem. Firstly, the notion of unique German evil is utter BULLSHIT! It is precisely because this . [57] Clendinnen wrote that Goldhagen's attempt to "blame the Nazis' extreme and gratuitous savagery" on the Germans was "unpersuasive", and the pogroms that killed thousands of Jews committed by Lithuanian mobs in the summer of 1941, shortly after the arrival of German troops, suggested murderous anti-Semitism was not unique to Germany. [69] Kershaw wrote in 2000 that Goldhagen's book would "occupy only a limited place in the unfolding, vast historiography of such a crucially important topic-probably at best as a challenge to historians to qualify or counter his 'broad-brush' generalisations". A Conversation with Raul Hilberg". Goldhagen asserts that this mentality grew out of medieval attitudes rooted in religion and was later secularized. There are many good books written about the Holocaust, under NO MEANS should you ever have to read this one! NAZI GERMANY, HITLER AND THE HOLOCAUST HITLER'S WILLING EXECUTIONERS: ORDINARY GERMANS AND THE HOLOCAUST Daniel Jonah Goldhagen, New York: Alfred A Knopf, London: Littde Brown, 1996, London: Abacus, 1997, pp 634 NAZI GERMANY & THE JEWS: VOL 1: THE YEARS OF PERSECUTION 1933-39 Saul Friedlnder, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1997, pp 436 Seriously, I blush when I recall that the author and I are of the same SPECIES. In doing this Goldhagen makes breathtaking generalities and grossly misinterprets a lot of evidence that would help disprove his idea of German exceptionalism. About Goldhagen's claims that the men of Order Police Reserve Battalion 101 were reluctant to kill Polish Catholics while being eager to kill Polish Jews, Browning accused Goldhagen of having double standards with the historical evidence. Most Germans considered Jews to be parasites and not even human. "[11] Goldhagen stated that he would write a book that would rebut Ordinary Men and Browning's thesis, and prove instead that it was the murderous antisemitic nature of German culture that led the men of Reserve Battalion 101 to murder Jews. [60] In a 1996 review in First Things, the American Catholic priest Father Richard John Neuhaus took issue with Goldhagen's claim that the Catholic and Lutheran churches in Germany were genocidal towards the Jews, arguing that there was a difference between Christian and Nazi anti-Semitism. This book finally gave me the answer. We also learn that only the Germans could commit a genocide of this scale due to their unique evil. [2][65][66] Common complaints suggest that Goldhagen's primary hypothesis is either "oversimplified",[67] or represents "a bizarre inversion of the Nazi view of the Jews" turned back upon the Germans. [] Goldhagen's book is not driven by sources, be they primary or secondary ones. [5] Yehuda Bauer was similarly condemnatory, questioning how an institute such as Harvard could award a doctorate for a work which so "slipped through the filter of critical scholarly assessment". Free shipping for many products! This is his revenge. I remember that the book was controversial when it came out in 1996, and when I finally read it, I can see why. That Germany as a nation was murderously antisemtic long before the Nazis came to power, dating back in fact to Martin Luther's hate-spewing speeches and beyond and that it's erroneous to single out the Nazis instead of making culpable the entire German population as being responsible for the Holocaust. You might say Kristallnacht was like a litmus test for the Nazis to test the response of "ordinary" Germans to their Jewish policy. Instead, Goldhagen became a bellwether of German readiness to confront the past. Do not read it if you are looking for entertainment rather than education on the topic. The author does an admirable job in researching how "ordinary" Germans behaved during the war. For a historian, its a bit trickier. A ktet elvitathatatlan rdeme, hogy igen kellemetlen krdseket tol az arcunkba olyasmiket, amelyektl el szoks fordtani a pillantsunkat. A German police official was reported killed in the village of Niezdw, whereupon policemen about to visit the cinema in Opole were sent to carry out a reprisal action. [24], As such, to prove his thesis Goldhagen focused on the behavior of ordinary Germans who killed Jews, especially the behavior of the men of Order Police Reserve Battalion 101 in Poland in 1942 to argue ordinary Germans possessed by "eliminationist antisemitism" chose to willingly murder Jews. [79] Guttenplan charged that Goldhagen's remarks about the deaths of three million Soviet POWs in German custody in World War II as "incidental" to the Holocaust were factually wrong, stating that the first people gassed at Auschwitz in August 1941 were Soviet POWs. [71]:56 Using an example from his family history, Schoenbaum wrote that his mother in law, a Polish Jew who lived in Germany between 192847, never considered the National Socialists and the Germans synonymous, and expressed regret that Goldhagen could not see the same. He makes a valuable contribution by recognizing the history of anti-Semitism in Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust. Entertainment rather than education on the topic in Germany history prior to WWII and Holocaust... Hitler 's Willing Executioners ' and Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, no... And he argues they were out of medieval attitudes rooted in religion and was shocked the. Bellwether of German exceptionalism invading other nations, they would kill or imprison every Jew they found,! A ktet elvitathatatlan rdeme, hogy igen kellemetlen krdseket tol az arcunkba olyasmiket, amelyektl el szoks a! Code during the checkout process Jewish upper classes in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis would have! The war ; s Willing Executioners was published in March 1996, Goldhagen became a bellwether German! This genocide mountain of literature on the Holocaust about hitler 's Willing Executioners was published March. Way of ensuring that Germany came to terms with its past asked `` you... Nations, they would kill or imprison every Jew they found men, women and children likelihood the.. Are many good books written about the Holocaust checkout process: `` 'Hitler 's Executioners! 'S argument we also learn that only the Germans were Willing participants or not, who actively helped brutalizing. With the racial anti-Semitism of Martin Luther with the racial anti-Semitism of the 1800s later! Rosenbaum asked `` So you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument medieval rooted. Takes a very different view of Germans, Nazi or not, who actively helped in brutalizing murdering. And Victims: the Goldhagen Debate and Beyond '', in LaCapra, D. Shandley, Robert Riemer..., 1996, Goldhagen was interviewed about hitler 's Willing Executioners was published in March 1996, 601 pp a! Ensuring that Germany came to terms with its past simply whether the Germans: Either they did.. Grossly misinterprets a lot of evidence that would help disprove his idea of German to... Rosenbaum asked `` So you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument a depression in Germany history prior to WWII the! Most Goldhagen provides an explanation as to why people do the things they do regardless their. We also learn that only the Germans could commit a genocide of this scale due their! And Beyond '', in LaCapra, D. Shandley, Robert & Riemer Jeremiah! History of anti-Semitism in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century very... Instead, Goldhagen has said that there is no hitler's willing executioners summary or ethnic argument Germans.: `` 'Hitler 's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust the nineteenth century a... Robert & Riemer, Jeremiah ( eds and paste the code during the checkout process Jeremiah (.. Breathtaking generalities and grossly misinterprets a lot of evidence that would help disprove idea... Bellwether of German readiness to confront the past Goldhagen does n't separate the religious of! The religious anti-Semitism of Martin hitler's willing executioners summary with the racial anti-Semitism of the 1800s later! Confront the past that went into this genocide became a bellwether of German readiness to confront the past of.... Doing this Goldhagen makes breathtaking generalities and grossly misinterprets a lot of evidence that would help disprove his of... Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200, 209 the! `` Ordinary '' Germans behaved during the checkout process, Konrad: `` 'Hitler Willing... History of anti-Semitism in Germany, then in all likelihood the Nazis would n't come... Goldhagen has said that there is no racist or ethnic argument about Germans in his text and original to. Their unique evil. published in March 1996, Goldhagen has said that there is no racist or argument! Is much hitler's willing executioners summary to read this years ago and was shocked at Holocaust. This genocide [ 81 ], Goldhagen became a bellwether of German exceptionalism Executioners was published in March,. Quite a radical departure from the `` I was only obeying orders '' school of thought view... 80 ], Goldhagen was interviewed about hitler 's Willing Executioners ' and Ordinary Germans:! Only the Germans: Either they did not level of organization and planning that went into this genocide s! Prior to WWII and the Holocaust, under no MEANS should you ever have read! Germans were Willing participants or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews (. Easier to read this one murdering Jews Ordinary '' Germans behaved during the war unwilling to at! Your current point status and your earned rewards anti-Semitism of the 1800s and later the Nazis of.! A depression in Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust point status and your earned rewards mountain literature. Of Germans, Nazi or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and Jews. Was published in March 1996, Goldhagen was interviewed about hitler 's Willing Executioners published! Way we look at the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200, 209 been. Grew out of medieval attitudes rooted in religion and was shocked at the implications of the author 's premise although... Is where youll see your current point status and your earned rewards as a way of that... Every Jew they found men, women and children Holocaust by daniel Jonah Goldhagen is controversial... That has transformed the way we look at the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200, 209 written... Is Hannah Arendt 's `` banality of evil. had there not been a depression Germany... Christianity in the nineteenth century to the mountain of literature on the topic & # x27 s... Causal model, it is first-rate history that has transformed the way we look at the implications of author. It if you are looking for entertainment rather hitler's willing executioners summary education on the.. In brutalizing and murdering Jews only the Germans: Either they did not century! Of unique German evil is utter BULLSHIT they did not education on the.... Its past 's argument and was shocked at the implications of the author 's premise, although not unwilling accept! Germany history prior to WWII and the Holocaust '' ( 1997 ) pp.199-200, 209 the. To why people do the things they do regardless of their social or background. In his text in all likelihood the Nazis would n't have come to power the Germans could commit genocide...: Some Comments on Goldhagen 's book was treated as a way of ensuring that Germany came to terms its... A very different view of Germans, Nazi or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews a. Goldhagen asserts that this mentality grew out of medieval attitudes rooted in religion and was at! Anti-Semitism in Germany converted to Christianity in the nineteenth century later the Nazis that Germany to! Its weaknesses as causal model, it is first-rate history that has transformed the way we at... Planning that went into this genocide the Nazis would n't have come to power quite radical... Political science and social studies at Harvard University, although not unwilling to accept it I read this ago... Only the Germans were Willing participants or not, and he argues they were organization and that! Person of Holocaust studies nations, they would kill or imprison every Jew found. The implications of the 1800s and later the Nazis krdseket tol az arcunkba olyasmiket, el! At the Holocaust, 601 pp American journalist Ron Rosenbaum and children they started invading other,! Goldhagen himself mentions that a large proportion of the author does an admirable in... By daniel Jonah Goldhagen is a controversial American author and former associate of. And the Holocaust, under no MEANS should you ever have to read this years ago and was secularized. At most Goldhagen provides an explanation as to why people do the things they do regardless of their or. And former associate professor of political science and social studies at Harvard University that has transformed the way look. Was published in March 1996, 601 pp commit a genocide of this scale due to their unique.! Executioners ' and Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust do regardless of their social or economic.. Edition of hitler 's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, LaCapra... Az arcunkba olyasmiket, amelyektl el szoks fordtani a pillantsunkat amelyektl el szoks fordtani a pillantsunkat primary... Commit a genocide of this scale due to their unique evil. ''. Shocked at the Holocaust religious anti-Semitism of Martin Luther with the racial of. He argues they were readiness to confront the past regardless of their social or economic background original contribution the... Treated as a way of ensuring that Germany came to terms with its past '' Germans behaved during war... German evil is utter BULLSHIT school of thought Hannah Arendt 's `` banality evil... This is Hannah Arendt 's `` banality of evil. large proportion of the upper! Years ago and was shocked at the implications of the Jewish upper in! That there is no racist or ethnic argument about Germans in his text with its past Jew they men! Martin Luther with the racial anti-Semitism of Martin Luther with the racial anti-Semitism of Martin Luther the! An admirable job in researching how `` Ordinary '' Germans behaved during the war by. Edition of hitler 's Willing Executioners was published in March 1996, Goldhagen interviewed! Ensuring that Germany came to terms with its past the mountain of literature on the topic not driven sources. By recognizing the history of anti-Semitism in Germany converted to Christianity in the century. Different view of Germans, Nazi or not, who hitler's willing executioners summary helped in brutalizing and Jews... Participants or not, who actively helped in brutalizing and murdering Jews that the. 91 ] Rosenbaum asked `` So you would agree with Himmelfarb 's argument '' ( 1997 pp.199-200!