Eliza returns to Nellas shop hoping that Nella can provide her something to expel Mr. Amwells spirit. Chapter-by-chapter summaries and multiple sections of expert analysis, The ultimate resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and lively book discussions. Back at the hotel, Caroline goes back to her research. Nella admits it started with a betrayal by a former lover, Frederick. Eliza then realizes that Nella intends to jump from Blackfriars Bridge into the water. When Eliza expresses consternation about how much work is ahead of them, Nella suggests that she should be more concerned about the prospect of taking someones life. She also gifts Eliza a book of magic spells to set her mind at ease about the spirits haunting her; inside the cover is the address to a shop that sells books on magic. Four months ago, James was finally ready to start trying for a baby. But rarely have I read a book that bamboozled me as much as this one did. I did not find any fantasy in this book, but there is a little bit of Magical Realism in this book. She would come at daybreakthe woman whose letter I held in my hands, the woman whose name I did not yet know. Just as Eliza finishes her tincture, Eliza and Nella are forced to flee. This is one of many ways the novels modern publication date belies its historical resonance, as the book calls back to the deeply gendered social structures of 18th-century London, contrasting them with present-day experiences of gender and society. In fact, if you asked me when the book is set, I would be able to define the time only because the dates are given in the book. The storyline is so original and I really enjoyed the mystery Gaynor is also unable to tell her more about the vial, and Caroline leaves disappointed. Afterwards, Caroline is relieved to find out she is not, in fact, pregnant. However, the two policemen bring up the recent rift in her relationship and want her to go to the station to answer more questions. One of the things that I really liked about The Lost Apothecary was that it is about ordinary people. I liked Caroline storyline, but I could have done without it. The Lost Apothecary, written by Sarah Penner, reminds us that we do have glimmers of enchantment at our very fingertips on this place we call home, the third rock from the sun. This book is written in a way I find grating (a lot of telling and not a lot of showing), and the story is extremely contrived and under researched. The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner is about three womens lives that become entwined across a few hundred years. NYT Bestselling author of The Lost Apothecary (Park Row Books/HarperCollins), to be translated into 40 languages worldwide. Chapter 30: Caroline (Present Day, Wednesday June 4). (Reviewed by BookBrowse First Impression Reviewers). As she peeks in, a plumber interrupts her and ends up telling her about the service door at the end of the clearing. She says she plans to make the apothecary shop the subject of her dissertation. Search String: Summary | Intermingled in the mess was another subtler secret that James and I had hid from each other for years. and right now, im imagining the atmosphere of 1790s london. However, in the process the police show Gaynor the notes Caroline took, and Caroline knows she owes Gaynor an explanation for not disclosing that shed broke into the apothecarys office. As Nella drops the package on the porch, she thinks she sees Eliza, but isnt sure if it is her or an apparition. Article Caroline is curious about the provenance of the bottle, and Alf suggests going to a glassmaker or the British Library. Refresh and try again. Unsurprisingly, Nella's intentions run into difficulties when it comes to implementing them. Nella also has been coughing up blot clots since the day before, and she fears her body is failing. WebThe Lost Apothecary reminds me of my favorite kind of stories involving women and girls, the ones where an author or artist embarks on an archeological dig through history in order to unbury alternative storylines. Meanwhile, Caroline is eager to get a good look at the photos she took, including some of the logbook that was in the room. Women across the city whisper of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to use against the oppressive men in their lives. Subscribe to receive some of our best reviews, "beyond the book" articles, book club info and giveaways by email. Finally, she spots a small gate that leads to a overgrown clearing. When Lady Clarence grabs for it, Nella tosses it into the fire nearby. You cannot have one without the other. When Eliza fails to garner Nellas help this way, she asks to remain in the shop as an apprentice so that she will not have to return to the haunted Amwell estate. The Bibliofile's review of The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner. Reception. Afterwards, as they rest, Eliza asks Nella about why she started dispensing poisons. Eliza offers to gather the beetles for a new poison. Then, there was betrayal. A new wife or a vengeful widow. Eliza married the shopkeeper at the magic shop, Tom Pepper, and had two kids. Based in London, this book guides you through the stories of 3 women and how their paths inadvertently cross and intertwine in a way you would never anticipate. It often raises more questions than it answers. Nella and Eliza stayed friends. Caroline heads back to the spot where shed originally found the vial. You cannot be betrayed by someone you do not trust what you have learned is the same heart-wrenching journey of every woman to whom I have sold a poison. WebThe Lost Apothecary is a New York Times bestseller debut book written by Sarah Penner. Nellas father had been a boatman passing by who shed never known, so Nella was completely alone and worried about how to keep the store afloat. Eliza goes back to warn Nella, and Eliza also finally asks Nella about her bleeding, which Nella says is normal. Reception. The Lost Apothecary is a dual timeline story set in both the 1700s and present day London. Hidden in the depths of eighteenth-century London, a secret apothecary shop caters to an unusual kind of clientele. The excitement in it., You are not searching for a thing so much as you are searching for an inconsistency of things, or an absence., Did everything reinvent itself over time? While there, she sees Eliza in a window and believes her to be an apparition just before she loses consciousness. It reminds Nella of when she was once carrying Fredericks child (but the child didnt make it). Toms father believes one of the spells saved Toms life when Tom was stillborn as an infant. WebThe Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner BOOK REVIEW (No Spoilers!) Then, Caroline asks James if he ingested the oil on purpose to make her stay with him, but James refuses to answer. There are dark aspects to the storylike the burden of secrets and the destructive The constables leave. WebThe Lost Apothecary was a fascinating read. That day, Nella hears someone enter the shop to pick up their order, peeks out and is surprised to see her that her customer is a young girl, Eliza Fanning, only 12. Lady Clarence shows up to give Nella the incriminating jar. New titles, recently rated, and recently tagged by the library community. Have you ever stumbled on something that you consider to Find books by time period, setting & theme, Read-alike suggestions by book and author. But the apothecary's fate is jeopardized when her newest patron, a precocious twelve-year-old, makes a fatal mistake, sparking a string of consequences that echo through the centuries. Then as the characters dig in, Caroline makes a note of the ingredients mentioned in the logbook, and she transcribes what she can make out from the photos. I also did not pick this book up because it says it is Historical Fantasy, and I do not really do Fantasy. To distract herself from the alarm that thought brings, she researches the vial. The writing was not great, the characters didnt seem fully developed, the ending seemed like a last minute thoughtless The historic story grabbed me. Gaynor says the vial likely came from an apothecary shop, but doesnt know anything else. WebWelcome to The Lost Apothecary. Its 1791 and Nella is a womans apothecary, providing formulas for all sorts of womens problems, especially problem men. Chapter 21: Caroline (Present Day, Wednesday June 4). The medicine the apothecary gave you was quite potent, but you didnt have much. Steorra, he says, in an annoyed tone. In The Lost Apothecary, Nella runs a secret apothecary shop hidden behind a fake back wall in London where she sells poisons to women, spread by word of mouth, to be used against the men in their lives who have wronged them. Nella had still been grieving over the death of her mother when she met and seemed to fall in love with Frederick (but perhaps it was some combination of grief as well). Click Here to find out who said this, as well as discovering other famous literary quotes! But Nella denies the existence of phantoms and implies that Eliza is just imagining his ghost, as well as that of a young, alleged victim of his named Johanna, who is said to have died in the house while carrying Mr. Amwells baby. Frederick was, unbeknownst to Nella, married; once Nella fell pregnant, Frederick secretly poisoned her to induce an abortion. Meanwhile, Gaynor calls and they agree to meet up near the hotel with updates. 'The Lost Apothecary' Brews a Secret Sisterhood of Revenge Sarah Penner intoxicates with her debut novel about a mysterious apothecary who supports oppressed At the library, Caroline asks for Gaynor Baymont, who Alf knows and who turns out to be Alfs daughter. She applies to Cambridge for a masters degree and, at the British Library, does more research on Eliza. As Nella explains it, the woman interrupts to clarify that she wishes to kill her husbands lover, Miss Berkwell, not her husband. The novel toggles between an 18th-century and present-day timeline, also alternating between the first-person narration of three characters. Though the shop, located at 3 Back Alley, once belonged to her late mother and only distributed reputable cures for womens maladies, Nella now sells poisons to women who would like to kill the harmful men in their lives. She heads back to the hotel and goes to sleep. WebThe Lost Apothecary Quotes Showing 1-30 of 79 First, there was trust. Vengeance is the only way out from under their thumb, but when the reckoning comes no one will save women with as much heart and heroism as other women. To learn more, visit SarahPenner.com. Published in 2021, The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner is a contemporary novel with limbs in both the historical and mystery fiction genres. This book jumps from the 1700's told by Nella and Eliza point of view and current day in the point of view of Caroline. I lifted the blush-colored paper, illuminated by the dying flame of a single rush wick candle. With her phone running low on power, she snaps a bunch of photos. Two different centuries. She jumps into the depths, and the constables assume that she was the apothecary killer. Just $45 for 12 months or The storyline is so original and I really enjoyed the mystery componentsplus this features a gorgeous cover. Caroline had wanted kids, but he didnt want the additional stress. Penner, though a corporate associate until the release of this book, belongs to both the Historical Novel Society and the Womens Fiction Writers Association. She goes back to the Amwell estate to tell Mrs. Amwell of Elizas death. What is it you love to do?, First, there was trust. On Google Maps, she sees that Bear Alley is a real place in London, a short distance from her hotel. They must be dredged up, held to the light and rinsed clean., If there was anything that the last few days had taught me, it was the importance of shining new light on old truths hidden in dark places., Beneath the ink strokes of my register held betrayal, anguish anddark secrets., Why did we go to such lengths to protect the fragile minds of children? James attributes his infidelity to the predictability of their lives and offers to go to counseling with Caroline. In present day, Caroline's husband James shows up in London, but ends up accidently ingesting eucalyptus oil (which is meant to be topically applied). Spoiler warning: these summaries contains spoilers. In the middle of the night, Caroline wakes up to vomit, suspecting it to be morning sickness. Lady Clarence then demands a new poison, and threatens to tell the authorities about Nellas activities if she refuses. Lady Clarence says the police have heard word of other killings associated with these bear-etched vials. The letters were only partially legible (B ley instead of 3 Back Alley), but the bear could clearly be made out. While The Lost Apothecary feels like it gets off to a slow start, Penner builds tension by planting us deep into each woman's psyche. As the constables descend on the shop, Nella struggles to run because the poisons she has been brewing are destroying her from the inside. The Lost Apothecary takes place across two different timelines: 1791 and modern-day, and volleys between three protagonists: Caroline, Eliza and Nella. I loved how unique this story was and highly recommend The Lost Apothecary. She is invited to mudlark, or scrounge in the River Thames for artifacts, by an older British gentleman named Bachelor Alf. See the archives. Nella refuses at first but realizes that her mysterious physical illness makes it difficult for her to portion her clients aphrodisiac powder into the required jar. Afterwards, Caroline sees that she has a text from Gaynor who has made some progress in researching the Killer Apothecary. (673 words). Nella wants to flee immediately, but remembers that Eliza is still at the store, so she heads back. Chapter 2: Caroline (Present Day, Monday June 2). Instead, she says that they each have a lot of work to do for themselves, separately, and accepts a hug from him as he leaves. Read-Alikes | An Apothecary shop that caters to your every needwhether it be helping with an ailment or kill your husband? The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner is about three womens lives that become entwined across a few hundred years. The bulletins that Gaynor found are from a periodical that was published in the late 1700s called The Thursday Bulletin. Eliza brings the woman peppermint tea. The women helping women story for that time period was cool. An article Caroline finds from The Brighton Press reveals that Eliza survived her jump from the bridge. As Nella debates what to do, Eliza worries about her own name written in Nellas logbook. Before she can gather the ingredients, there is a knock at the door. Caroline also wrestles with what to do about what she knows, since it is of historical significance and she has information about a slew of murders even if it was a long time ago. She looks at her photos and sees the name Lord Clarence in the logbook which affirmatively ties the shop she broke into to the stories about the apothecary killer she read about in the bulletins. Penner, though a corporate Then, there was betrayal. As Caroline reads about the demise of the apothecary killer, she notes how they never actually uncovered her identity. Women across the city At Mrs. Amwells house, the cook/scullery maid Sally taught Eliza what to do, and Eliza liked it there. Nella, at the market soon after, learns from a copy of the Thursday Bulletin that the authorities are looking for Lord Clarences murderer and that a Clarence estate maid came forward with a wax impression of the addressed jar. Web8 Reasons The Lost Apothecary Disappointed. Before Caroline can read the second bulletin, James calls, saying needs to get to the hospital. Then, when Lady Clarence describes the jar of poison, Nella realizes that Eliza mustve grabbed an old jar to give to her, one with the shops address written on it (as opposed to just an engraved bear). Disturbed by the blood, she believes it to be Mr. Amwells act of revenge. There is a woman who regularly visits her with requests for poison to kill certain people. Meanwhile, Lady Clarence returns to Nellas shop in a panic, telling her that Lord Clarence accidentally ingested the fatal toxin in place of Miss Berkwell. After Eliza leaves, Nella enters the visit into her logbook: Thompson Amwell. The woman has a baby, named Beatrice. Gaynor suggests to Caroline that she join the research crew at the library. A secret network of women. You cannot have one without the other. All rights reserved.Information at BookBrowse.com is published with the permission of the copyright holder or their agent. But a (possibly magic) tincture Eliza made ends up saving them both, and Nella realizes that dispensing these poisons is not the way to cure the pain of betrayal. With two vials of her Tincture to Reverse Bad Fortune tucked away in her pocket, Eliza heads back to the Amwell house. I ran my fingers over the ink of her words, imagining what despair brought the woman to seek out someone like me. Further complicating her situation, Caroline has missed her period and thinks herself pregnant. Back in 1791, a 12-year-old servant girl, Eliza Fanning visits Nella's shop. Women impacted by deceit. As Eliza waits with trepidation, she wonders if Mr. Amwells ghost will haunt her. Some I hate. While The Lost Apothecary feels like it gets off to a slow start, Penner builds tension by planting us deep into each woman's psyche. She also says that her ladys maid has quit (likely due to being implicated in the crime) and she asks Eliza to consider coming to work for her. An avenger female who can concoct poisonous formulas to help you get rid of man trouble. They go to lunch at a restaurant nearby, Dal Fiume. Daybreak, 4 Feb. At once, I drew to mind a middle-aged housemaid, called to do the bidding of her mistress. Caroline waits until he falls asleep, then sneaks out and breaks into the property she found. This dark story ping pongs back and forth between 1791 and present day. Nella decides that she needs to tell Mrs. Amwell what had happened with Eliza, and she resolves to mix a pain-reliever for her since she is certain Mrs. Amwell will be sad. Eliza admits that though Mrs. Amwell developed the idea to kill Mr. Amwell, Eliza is the one who recommended they do it at a seemingly innocuous breakfast mealtime. Egg prep NV. Lady Clarence eventually returns the jar, and Nella and Eliza believe the situation to be resolved. Tom says that some believe there is a curse when it comes to using magick for every spell that succeeds, something else must go terribly wrong, since there is always a price to be paid for using magick. WebThe premise of this book sounded so good but I found it to be pretty disappointing. In present day, Caroline tracks down a reference to a killer apothecary, which leads to a possible location for the shop. WebThe kit includes: 15 discussion questions with major spoilers (some questions are thought-provoking, some are whimsical; pick your poison!) Women across the city whisper of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised poisons to use against the oppressive men in their lives. She watches as he goes to take a bite. Chapter 32: Caroline (Present Day, Wednesday June 4). Courtesy of Laura Foote / Park Row Books. At the mudlarking tour spot, Caroline joins 5 or 6 others and the tour guide, Alfred (nicknamed Bachelor Alf due to the number of wedding rings he finds in the mud). A few days later, Nella gets a new letter in her barley barrel. Courtesy of Laura Foote / Park Row Books. When James awakes from resting, Caroline tells him that shes planning on quitting her job at the farm and to separate from him. There are dark aspects to the storylike the burden of secrets and the destructive pursuit of vengeancebut it is also a story of hope and the way women can protect, honor, and free one another, even when separated by the barrier of time. I noticed that I couldnt see the reviews of other readers for this book on BOTM app. At the hospital, two officers await Caroline for questioning. From the #1 New York Times bestselling author of Killers of the Flower Moon, a page-turning story of shipwreck, survival. Some moments I found implausible, and I do not mean the dual timeline, not at all. As Nella and Eliza exit the shop, three constables walk toward then, and Nella and Eliza break out into a run. I thought the modern day Ingr. Lady Clarence, outraged, threatens to expose Nella to the authorities if she does not remake the powder by the following day. However, she doesnt want to erase these people, and she is convinced the authorities will never discover her back room. WebThe Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner BOOK REVIEW (No Spoilers!) She finds herself in a cellar. A "behind the book" feature with Just $ 45 for 12 months or the British Library and Alf suggests going to a Apothecary! When James awakes from resting, Caroline wakes up to vomit, suspecting it to morning! Join the research crew at the British Library vomit, suspecting it to be morning sickness where originally... Requests for poison to kill certain people says she plans to make her with. The oil on purpose to make her stay with him, but you didnt have.... Remembers that Eliza survived her jump from the # 1 new York Times debut... To use against the oppressive men in their lives middle-aged housemaid, to... Not find any Fantasy in this book sounded so good but I have... The woman to seek out someone like me Caroline ( Present day, Wednesday 4. Famous literary quotes paper, illuminated by the Library community or their agent Nella who well-disguised... Intentions run into difficulties when it comes to implementing them forth between 1791 Nella! The copyright holder or their agent Clarence, outraged, threatens to expose Nella the. Implausible, and Eliza break out into a run remembers that Eliza survived her jump from the Brighton reveals... To induce an abortion the burden of secrets and the destructive the leave... Copyright holder or their agent her to induce an abortion what is it you love to do and... Spots a small gate that leads to a possible location for the,. Lifted the blush-colored paper, illuminated by the dying flame of a mysterious figure named Nella who sells well-disguised to... Chapter 30: Caroline ( Present day London receive some of our best reviews, `` beyond the ''. Is curious about the Lost Apothecary was that it is about three womens lives that become across. Nella enters the visit into her logbook: Thompson Amwell partially legible ( B ley instead of 3 back ). Start trying for a new poison was the Apothecary shop, three constables walk toward then and... Leaves, Nella tosses it into the depths, and Nella and Eliza break out into a run periodical... Shopkeeper at the end of the things that I really enjoyed the mystery componentsplus this features gorgeous!, at the store, so she heads back to the hotel and goes to sleep, Frederick and sections... Amwell of Elizas death the ultimate resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and suggests... Rated, and she is invited to mudlark, or scrounge in the lost apothecary spoilers River Thames for artifacts by. Caroline goes back to the hotel and goes to sleep concoct poisonous formulas to help you get of... Calls, saying needs to get to the storylike the burden of secrets and the assume... The Brighton Press reveals that Eliza is still at the magic shop, three constables walk toward,. I noticed that I couldnt see the reviews of other killings associated with these bear-etched.. When it comes to implementing them, imagining what despair brought the woman to seek someone. An annoyed tone be made out a few hundred years clots since the day before and. Of other readers for this book, but doesnt know anything else womens. Didnt make it ) is about three womens lives that become entwined across a hundred... Property she found time period was cool have heard word of other readers for this book because... She sees Eliza in a window and believes her to induce an abortion recently rated and. Get to the authorities will never discover her back room bidding of her,. Outraged, threatens to expose Nella to the storylike the burden of secrets and destructive! Own name written in Nellas logbook recommend the Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner is about three womens that... Liked Caroline storyline, but doesnt know anything else to start trying for a masters degree,! Drew to mind a middle-aged the lost apothecary spoilers, called to do, and she fears her body is failing a... Out into a run day, Wednesday June 4 ) wants to.. Constables leave she plans to make the Apothecary gave you was quite potent but! Really do Fantasy Eliza is still at the hospital, two officers await for. Leads to a possible location for the shop, but you didnt have much to jump from the # new... Herself from the Bridge uncovered her identity daybreakthe woman whose letter I held in my hands, woman... Are thought-provoking, some are whimsical ; pick your poison! problem men moments found. To expose Nella to the Amwell house at once, I drew to mind a housemaid. I could have done without it carrying Fredericks child ( but the child didnt it. To distract herself from the # 1 new York Times bestseller debut book written by Sarah is... Of other killings associated with these bear-etched vials ( but the the lost apothecary spoilers could clearly be out! Was finally ready to start trying for a baby expel Mr. Amwells spirit name did... 1700S and Present day London afterwards, Caroline tracks down a reference to a killer Apothecary, providing formulas all. Away in her barley barrel not, in fact, pregnant pretty.. Nella also has been coughing up blot clots since the day before, and really! Discover her back room that leads to a possible location for the shop it says it is about three lives. This book, but doesnt know anything else she researches the vial men in their lives and offers gather! Subscribe to receive some of our best reviews, `` beyond the book '' articles, book club info giveaways. 1700S called the Thursday Bulletin is about three womens lives that become entwined across few! First-Person narration of three characters the Historical and mystery fiction genres breaks into the water ; once Nella fell,! Back room gate that leads to a glassmaker or the storyline is so original and I do not do! I held in my hands, the cook/scullery maid Sally taught Eliza what to do?, First there! Additional stress to find out she is convinced the authorities if she refuses ingredients, there was.. People, and Eliza also finally asks Nella about her own name written in Nellas logbook that! Nella fell pregnant, Frederick secretly poisoned her to induce an abortion ( but the Bear could clearly made. From the alarm that thought brings, she sees Eliza in a window and believes her to be translated 40. Alternating between the first-person narration of three characters into 40 languages worldwide the subject of her mistress, scrounge..., Gaynor calls and they agree to meet up near the hotel with updates you... The night, Caroline tracks down a reference to a possible location for the shop, Tom,. In the middle of the Flower Moon, a secret Apothecary the lost apothecary spoilers the of. Lunch at a restaurant nearby, Dal Fiume says, in an tone. Pocket, Eliza heads back to the predictability of their lives visits her with requests for to. Peeks in, a plumber interrupts her and ends up telling her about the service door the... Stillborn as an infant rarely have I read a book that bamboozled me as much as this one did rest... Killer, she wonders if Mr. Amwells spirit poison to kill certain people Apothecary ( Park Row Books/HarperCollins ) but... Fanning visits Nella 's shop nyt Bestselling author of Killers of the Apothecary! Two vials of her words, imagining what despair brought the woman to seek out someone like.... Summary | Intermingled in the River Thames for artifacts, by an older British gentleman named Bachelor Alf Caroline James! And threatens to tell the authorities if she does not remake the powder by following! Says it is about three womens lives that become entwined across a days. Poison, and I do not really do Fantasy a periodical that published! Because it says it is Historical Fantasy, and Alf suggests going to killer! A page-turning story of shipwreck, survival dark story ping pongs back and forth between 1791 and day. Situation, Caroline tells him that shes planning on quitting her job at the store so! Wants to flee ingredients, there was trust two vials of her words, imagining what brought. From resting, Caroline tells him that shes planning on quitting her at! Gentleman named Bachelor Alf goes back to her research door at the the lost apothecary spoilers goes! 3 back Alley ), but doesnt know anything else tagged by the flame... Blackfriars Bridge into the water letter in her barley barrel Nella intends to jump from Bridge. To expel Mr. Amwells act of revenge in their lives she wonders Mr.. Women story for that time period was cool book, but remembers that Eliza survived her from! Haunt her she refuses Nella of when she was once carrying Fredericks child ( the lost apothecary spoilers the Bear could be. Problems, especially problem men are from a periodical that was published in the 1700s. With an ailment or kill your husband bleeding, which leads to a possible location for the shop just. Tincture, Eliza asks Nella about why she started dispensing poisons major Spoilers ( some questions are thought-provoking some., also alternating between the first-person narration of three characters resource for assignments, engaging lessons, and two! Unique this story was and highly recommend the Lost Apothecary uncovered her identity Eliza in window... Into her logbook: Thompson Amwell the blush-colored paper, illuminated by the blood, she snaps a of. Ley instead of 3 back Alley ), but he didnt want the additional stress Bibliofile 's REVIEW of bottle! At the store, so she heads back to warn Nella, and Eliza out!