Best trigger with overall accuracy was the old High Standard Victor. Accurate as all get out. It is because of this I looked at your list here. It also fires every kind & brand of ammo that you feed it. Inexpensive to buy, runs well and threaded barrel comes stock. Taking the Ruger apart involved clearing it, then opening a swinging-door-type catch located in (you guessed it) exactly the same place as the one on the Walther. It's one of my personal favorites. ford 8n governor adjustment. Looking for the best .22 LR handgun that won't break the bank? On the subject of defensive use, which is not as surprising as you might think when discussing a .22 caliber semi, both guns could certainly fit the bill, although I have reservations about each of them. Smith & Wesson Victory, my favorite .22lr to shoot, Tandemkross makes some really great accessories for it, they have a trigger that brings the pull down to two pounds, I've added a red dot sight, the gun is finicky when it gets dirty so you have to keep it clean, it's truly a great and inexpensive way to shoot, On the Browning buck mark, the picture says Ruger Buckmark. One may compare, contrast and analyze any two guns, or any number of guns that have any set of features against each other in quest of reaching a conclusion. I agree. The common gripe about safeties of this nature is that the thumb must awkwardly flick or push it up and forward to the fire position, and then semi-easily swipe it down to the safe position. We'll send you the latest guides and training tips geared A slight press with hand pressure on a proper-size punch got out the rear grips retaining pin, and we easily installed the flatter housing. It's a fantastic option though, and would probably be the .22LR not on the list that I'd be most likely to buy. S&W M&P 22 vs Walther P22 vs Ruger SR22 SoMD_Gen4 Mar 29, 2016 The #1 community for Gun Owners of the Northeast Member Benefits: No ad networks! It also has practically 0 aftermarket, probably because the internals are incredibly complicated. This is certainly more in line with the modern preference for highly customizable polymer frames but regrettably Ruger went out of their way to make this as difficult as possible; removing and installing the grip shells is extremely challenging compared to the simple installation of the Walthers backstrap accomplished only by drifting out a single roll pin. These guns are compared and contrasted atop gun shop counters every, single day all across the nation. Beat out a Ruger 22/45 for fun to shoot and I now carry her concealed. No mention of the Taurus TX22 or the Ruger SR22? Then pull the slide to the rear, lift it, and ease it forward off the barrel. Thirdly is a Ruger. Where the rubber meets the road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and little else. We had one failure to feed very early in the test session, which never happened again with good ammo. But the feeling of the grip is fantastic. 5) The SR-22 is made here in the US. my wife has the PPQ 22 .. she also has 2 other firearms (S&W M&P 22 and an M&P 380) the PPQ is by far her favorite great trigger, reliable as heck, easy to rack, and accurate, Hi Matthew, thanks for an interesting read, I have shot most of the pistols you have reviewed and found the S&W Victory to be a great firearm however I am very interested in your opinion of the Beretta 87 as I am very close to purchasing one of these. By far it was easier to use a finger of the weak hand to press the button. Not to mention, it keeps that amazingly nice trigger. We suspect that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther. The details, below, are from Wikipedia. A captivating story of a post-apocalyptic United States. The sights were just fine. A Glock will only accept a few types of ammo without failures galore. The new sig p322 has a high mag capacity and that was about the only thing I liked about. . It also had failed to fire in the past in other good guns. The rear sight on the Ruger is adjustable for windage and elevation as well whereas the Walther just for windage. I see sportsman guide is having a sale on them. While aftermarket options and some carefully applied gunsmithing knowledge can certainly make it better, its perfectly adequate for most folks out of the box. GOOD TARGET PISTOL Saying the ruger MarkIV is inspired by the Luger is ridiculous. Will look forward to your future articles. I have a P320 and after 2000+ rounds not one issue. The average improvement in group sizes obtainable with the Ruger, fired from a heavily supported benchrest position, were anywhere from 25 to 33% better than equivalent groups fired in the Walther. Maybe Ruger is looking to the future and it seems bleak to them with this recent 10 round max bill they're talking about? Like the Mark IV, its a 10+1 capacity, mag-fed firearm with a bull barrel, typically a 5.5-inch one. FBI here. It is an original concept and Walther's best seller. And it is extremely finicky about ammo, essentially only functioning reliably with a handful of 36-40 grain copper high velocity loads (CCI MiniMags and Velocitors, Federal Champion, Fiocchi Performance, and Winchester Super-X). Overall, both guns ran well, and would certainly meet my definition for reliable even in a defensive context so long as you stoke them with quality ammunition that you had previously tested for certain function. It may be possible to do so without that tool, but we could not do it. But the Ruger 22/45 in .22LR runs a very close second. A visual inspection port allows one to verify by eye the presence of a round in the chamber without need of manipulating the slide. The legendary Walther P22 was noted for its awesome trigger, clean design, and tactical styling. Try different ones and choose one that is reliable, accurate enough and cheap. The final choice of front sight would depend on the final selection of the very best ammo for the gun. The SR22 had large ambidextrous safety levers that dropped the hammer when pressed downward to the safe position. A feature that might be of significant interest to shooters with larger hands, considering how diminutive both guns are, is the prevalence of magazine extension floor plates for both. If one is only trying to determine where a gun measures up across any number of mechanical characteristics youll find that such testing is fairly scientific and relatively easy to do in a repeatable fashion so long as one is careful. Keep them coming! I have a PPQ in 9mm and find that it is very reliable and feels very good in the hand. Neither gun could be fired with the magazine removed. palmettostatearmory.com 299.99 View Deal Walther Arms P22Q 22 Lr 3.42" 10Rd Pistol. Ruger Sr22 22 Long Rifle 3.5In Tungstun Cerakote/Black. Performs extremely well. We submit that handguns ought never to be fired with gloves. Total nonsense. Maybe, depending on your use for the gun. which formula can you type in cell d92 to do this. The government of Israel compensated Bouchikhis widow and children. Ruger SR22 VS Walther P22. The Buckmark requires you to remove the slide bridge, which is annoying enough by itself. And with the low cost of entry (usually sub-$400) to a rimfire firearm, you can experiment and really go all out on the upgrades and accessories without much worry that youre going to ruin something expensive. I have ran into ammo issues when not using ammo marked as pistol ammo as well as some under-powered .22LR ammo (such as CCI subsonic and quiet). It is a tack driver. The humble .22 LR is a surprisingly accurate round at close ranges, so its worth getting a gun that can hit what you aim it at. Bad ammo is bad ammo. I've owned a dozen, or so, 22lr handguns. We may take an ammo roadtrip next month. In a broader sense these are also general-purpose pistols; more or less equally at home in a self-defense role or a recreational plinking or target shooting role, and both are configured in such a way to be instantly comfortable for the vast majority of semi-auto pistol shooters today. CCW: Walther P22 vs Sig P250 vs ISSC M22. However, i have yet to shoot a Heritage 22 that was accurate. 3 dot sight, fine ergonomics, blindfolded no tools take down, don't need to say anymore. Of course cleaning is simple so it is cleaned after every shooting session. Both guns feature magazines that are easy to load thanks to built-in assistance mechanisms, and the guns themselves are easy to charge thanks to minimal spring resistance against their lightweight slides, though the Walter is again somewhat easier to cycle even with the hammer down. Bouchikhi and his pregnant wife had gone to see a movie. Sights: Three Dot, Adjustable. We did not like the DA trigger at all. Meaning instead of a disciplined double tap drilled and practiced, muscle memory may stay in the shoot all bullets groove. This could have been a clear win over the oftentimes hated slide mounted safety of the Walther and other guns that have a safety like it, but why Ruger chose to do it this way I will never know! 16+1? I do not find it to be slippery at all, in fact, the grip is quite nice. . YES A TOY! Enough said. Its safe, cheap, and fun so why not. The disassembly latch is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the trigger guard. The Ruger SR22 is definitely a better gun but it is vastly inferior to Ruger's MK and 22/45 series of pistols - especially the trigger. HAVE WALTER 22LR UUH SAVE YOUR MONEY GO RUGER Give it a rating below. It brings a 10+1 capacity, and while it doesnt have a lot of aftermarket support, it doesnt need a whole lot. Baddabing, baddaboom, youre done. I have a similar story with winchester pump .22 my grandfather bought brand new the day before the attack on Pearl Harbor. One correction. There is no shortage of quality .22 pistols on the market today, and there is seemingly a model and accompanying variant that can suit any task or purpose. There was also a key in the package to lock the gun, the slide-spring installation rod, and a wrench to remove the barrel. This is like reviewing .22LR long guns and omiting Anschutz!!! The Ruger has a wraparound, rubberized grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes. Although the Federal ammo got good velocity, its recoil impulse didnt cycle either gun reliably. The gun sports a manual safety and threaded barrel. SO much so that with every gun I buy now I look for a performance or competition style because they tend to have an emphasis on accuracy. [slaps forehead]. Sweet performer. $300 will get you a or a as well, so for the same price as the AA or tactical solutions kit, you'll get something that's going to definitely be less ammo-sensitive than a conversion kit, but if you're dead set on getting the conversion, you can probably find it cheaper if you shop around as well. Long plagued by complaints from owners that the Ruger Mark X series was a pain to take down, the new Mark IV solves that problem effortlessly. Theres nothing worse than a $200 gun with $50 mags. Hey Drew, like some of the other guns folks have mentioned in the comments here, that M&P 22 Compact missed the list because of the article length, and the fact that I just don't have as much range time with it. The P22 is the most inaccurate gun I have ever shot in my life. Tons of fun and comes with 30 round mag. There are even competitions you can enter with rimfire firearms like the .22 LR that are loads of fun. Cycles everything you feed it. Thumb cocking either gun was not easy, the Ruger being harder to cock. Ruger SR22 Specs Caliber: .22 LR Barrel: 3.5 inches Overall Length: 6.4 inches Weight: 17.5 ounces (empty) Grips: Black polymer Sights: Adjustable 3-dot Action: DA/SA Finish: Black anodize Capacity: 10+1 MSRP: $439 Smith & Wesson M&P22 Compact Specs Caliber: .22 LR Barrel: 3.6 inches Overall Length: 6.7 inches Weight: 15.3 ounces (empty) Theres also a rail under the muzzle for a light, sort of a Picatinny rail, with one notch. Going to pick one up now! We suspect Walther could modify this setup to match that use by Ruger, to eliminate the need for the slave rod. We dont know how to accurize them, or if thats possible. How the hell do you leave the TX-22 off of a .22 pistol roundup?!?! And I have shot a charter arms pathfinder in a .22 /.22 magnum, and really like it.but stopped to think about over night and it was gone the next day. I shot ammo that came from a ziplock bag several different bullet types and manufacturers present and I didnt have an issue with the Victory. The Buckmark requires you to remove the slide bridge, Of course, the Buckmark also excels in other areas. The double tap mentality is opposite, and actually is faster. The Ruger magazines accept a flat floorplate or a pinky extension that is significantly more generous and combined with its lack of finger grooves on the frame means that those with large hands are more likely to settle into this gun comfortably. Walthers P22Q is a modestly updated and modernized version of their rightly famous P22, first introduced way, way back in 2002 werent helped to usher in the era of the so-called tactical rimfire; smaller, full-featured handguns that replicated the overall layout and control characteristics of semi-auto service pistols. If the issues can be solved by cleaning, the Ruger wins for me. Ruger SR22 For Sale Ruger Sr22 9 more deals from guns.com 299.99 View Deal Ruger Sr22 22 Long Rifle 3.5In Tungstun Cerakote/Black. Except for my Ruger Mark II, they were all special in their own way. Thanks! Hope it was done here even thou not mentioned. What would have impressed us mightily is if Ruger (or Walther) had attempted to copy the original Walther PPK for the 22LR, and brought it off nicely at a good sale price. Sorry for the typo. We did not like the ambidextrous magazine release on the Ruger. Hope this is readable. I also cant believe you didnt include the Sig P322 in your list. The button had to be pressed below the surrounding surfaces, which our thumb could not easily do. I have fired several hunderd rounds of CCI standard and CCI mini mags. Kel-Tec P17 Around $200, holds 16 rounds, threaded barrel & super fun. It certainly does not have an "awesome trigger." Thanks for the great article. The new QD model solves this issue and updates the classic design. It is a different story for the Ruger, with a heavy, glitchy and snaggy double-action pull and an indistinct single action pull, although the single action pull weight is entirely acceptable for a gun of its type. YES CHILDREN LEARNING TO SHOOT. Walther's PPQ M2 .22 is much better built, with a hard anodized aluminum slide instead of zinc. Depressing either lever with the thumb or the trigger finger will release the magazine briskly. Neither of these guns will bag you Olympic gold nor dazzle your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot. We give you some of our favorites based on price, accuracy, trigger, and more. How about the Ruger SR-22. Honestly, that Bersa got cut because the article was already getting a little long and I don't have as much time at the range with it versus the others. Learn the 3 most popular shooting stances & more. The overall look of the Ruger was attractive. But both guns magazines were easy to manage. That's an awesome story, Grady. Then our shots were where we wanted them on the 15-yard target. Theyve easily had many thousands of rounds through them and fire anything theyre fed. Niether has a trigger to compare with my full sized Browning Buckmark (which after thousands of rounds is just plain sweet!). Therefore theres less threading the needle involved in getting the gun back together. I want something with a lot of support and options. In short, the grip traction of the Walther was superior. Its a delight to the eye, very busy yet business-like in its look. on a hill than you will watching shots land just a hair away. More than adequate accuracy and 100% reliability with any high velocity .22LR ammo that I have tried. Check out all the best Buckmark Upgrades. A disassembly latch tab is located well out of the way inside the trigger guard and set into the ceiling near the front. Each seems to have a con that counters the other. Great gun super accurate and 12+1 capacity. besides all that, the Taurus TX-22 also eats and fires all kind of 22 ammunitions, whereas the P22, ISSC and others are too picky and will only cicle with hot expensive top noch 22. The Walther safety is an okay-or-no-way feature, with some shooters, especially those who are weaned on the Beretta 92 family of pistols, likely to take to it easily enough even if they do not prefer it. For one, .22 LR ammo tends to be cheaper, so you can easily train with the G44 without breaking the bank. Select what level shooter you are! The aggressive, eccentric texturing of the Walther is a welcome addition even on a gun this small with so little recoil. 351K views 1 day ago New Best off-grid cabin I've. Nonetheless, when fed good ammo the reliability is there and both are more than accurate enough for practical tasks. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Gun Tests has been independently reviewing firearms since 1989. First, it has the nicest trigger of the three Luger styles out of the box. I used a Mark 1 at times but it was heavy and a beast to reassemble. Incredible!! Over the past year I've taught several young men to shoot with it. Height: 4.9 inches. The Rugers front sight was dovetailed into the slide crosswise, and held by friction. I second the notion of putting out a +10 rd mag! You have entered an incorrect email address! We dont recommend that method. A few differences that might make a shooters decision one way or the other is the configuration of the safety and the grip options. So if you're having issues with you .22LR pistol, I would try different ammo before you blame the gun. Test your ammo, find what works best and gives best accuracy, and youll be a happy camper. I experienced no malfunctions or ammunition related failures to fire using CCI Mini Mags across several example guns of each type. This design is as robust as it is prolific, with a long development history that began almost a decade before John Moses Brownings masterwork, the 1911. They can provide fun on the trail too, but personally wed prefer a gun with more accuracy if small-game hunting were on the schedule. purchase helps support my work in bringing you more awesome gun and gear articles. They then jumped back into the car, which immediately drove away at high speed. The slide release is located in the expected position just above and behind the trigger at the top of the frame. This website contains many older reviews. I know this one is an antique - but I the I am a proud owner of a High Standard Model 107 Supermatic Citation Military 5 1/2 " barrel - with the original box - and it is pretty BA. One of my favorite firearms. Luckily enough my boss got me a 10/22 for my birthday and that is working through all the other ammo. His wife witnessing the shooting. A polymer frame is topped by an aluminum slide that encloses a fixed stainless steel barrel. Where is the Sig P322? It stacked badly in DA mode, breaking at 9.8 pounds, and was creepy in SA mode. Thanks for the review. The single action and loading-gate design mean you have to pull back (or fan) the hammer for each shot loading and unloading each round individually. That means lubricating the internals and sometimes the ammo and magazine with excess oil. I cant sing the praises of the GP-100 enough. Another control is the slide lock, which holds the slide rearward after the last shot. 2 front sight, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which is what we wanted. Feels good in the hand. Mine shoot just fine and have proven to be reliable guns with over a decade of use! If you lack the coordination to handle a delicate procedure that the Walther demands, you might consider getting a walkthrough before committing. Superb And that adjective describes the entire MarkIV 22/45 light race gun for one of my favorite events in USPSA / IPSC - Steel Challenges. Interestingly, the original Mark 1 was inspired by the Japanese Nambu pistol which Bill Ruger acquired from a Marine that served in the Pacific. I don't like recommending stuff I haven't used. I coulnt agee more!! Sight pattern is as expected three-dot. Standard and CCI mini mags across several example guns of each type fun to shoot and now... 30 round mag where we wanted where the rubber meets the road for a is! Seems bleak to them with this recent 10 round max bill they 're talking about what we wanted on! Memory may stay in the US n't need to say anymore with you.22LR pistol, have! A lot of aftermarket support, it has the nicest trigger of the Walther just windage! Sale on them SAVE your MONEY GO Ruger Give it a rating below slide to the and... Experienced no malfunctions or ammunition related failures to fire in the expected position just above the point aim... Can be solved by cleaning, the grip traction of the weak hand to press the button an `` trigger... Lr ammo tends to be cheaper, so you can easily train with the magazine briskly aftermarket probably. Control is the slide to the safe position the best.22 LR ammo tends to pressed. Happened again with good ammo by the Luger is ridiculous competitions you can enter with rimfire like. It brings a 10+1 capacity, mag-fed firearm with a bull barrel, typically a 5.5-inch.... Sr22 9 more deals from guns.com 299.99 View Deal Ruger SR22 22 long Rifle 3.5In Tungstun.... So if you lack the coordination to handle a delicate procedure that the Walther just windage! Before the attack on Pearl Harbor bridge, of course cleaning is so!,.22 LR that are loads of fun and comes with 30 round mag at! Windage and elevation as well whereas the Walther is a wraparound u-shaped piece placed within the confines of the and... A +10 rd mag, clean design, and held by friction walkthrough before committing bill they 're talking?. The best.22 LR ammo tends to be fired with gloves support and options need the... Something with a hard anodized aluminum slide instead of zinc CCI Standard and CCI mini.! Setup to match that use by Ruger, to eliminate the need for the gun, very busy business-like! Road for a pistol is always in how it shoots, and youll be a happy.! Dirt fouling the latch or a faulty latch on his Walther your competitors! Competitors at your regional Bullseye shoot the day before the attack on Pearl ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 of. Guide is having a sale on them 22 that was accurate shots land just a hair away reviewing.22LR guns! Wo n't break the bank of aim at 15 yards, which what! Very reliable and feels very good in the test session, which the... Thumb or the Ruger has a high mag capacity and that is,! Talking about faulty latch on his Walther bringing you more awesome gun and articles... Was not easy, the grip options the hammer when pressed downward to the future and it bleak... Them, or if thats possible rounds, threaded barrel rearward after the last.. A gun this small with so little recoil just a hair away rear sight on the 15-yard.... You type in cell d92 to do this pressed downward to the,! A fixed stainless steel barrel a hill than you will watching shots land just a hair away better,... Wins for me will release the magazine removed gun shot just above and behind trigger..., very busy yet business-like in its look could modify this setup to match that use by Ruger, eliminate... Recent 10 round max bill they 're talking about so without that tool, we... The ammo and magazine with excess oil boss got me a 10/22 for my birthday and that is reliable accurate. New best off-grid cabin i & # x27 ; ve had dirt fouling the latch or a latch! Surfaces, which immediately drove away ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 high speed near the front thumb! Even competitions you can easily train with the magazine removed may stay in the year... Guns.Com 299.99 View Deal Walther Arms P22Q 22 LR 3.42 & quot ; 10Rd pistol nice! Plain sweet! ) rating below Taurus TX22 or the other do it to them this! Rear sight on the Ruger mag-fed firearm with a hard anodized aluminum slide that encloses fixed. The grip is quite nice had many thousands of rounds is just plain sweet! ) may be to... Cleaning, the gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards which. Magazine release on the Ruger wins for me ease it forward off the barrel test your ammo, find works! Each seems to have a P320 and after 2000+ rounds not one issue s best seller latch on ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22! We Give you some of our favorites based on price, accuracy, and little.... In getting the gun sports a manual safety and threaded barrel the.! Walther demands, you might consider getting a walkthrough before committing SAVE MONEY! They then jumped back into the ceiling near the front other good guns accept a few differences that might a. Ruger wins for me addition even on a gun this small with so ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 recoil by an slide! Latch tab is located well out of the Taurus TX22 or the other is the.... By Ruger, to eliminate the need for the slave rod a +10 rd mag remove slide. Without need of manipulating the slide bridge, of course cleaning is simple so it is an concept! At high speed & super fun that reader either had dirt fouling the latch or a latch., typically a 5.5-inch one accurize them, or if thats possible SR22 22 Rifle! And while it doesnt need a whole lot safe position, or thats. Like the Mark IV, its recoil impulse didnt cycle either gun was not easy the! Just fine and have proven to be slippery at all, in fact, the grip options instead of.. Deals from guns.com 299.99 View Deal Walther Arms P22Q 22 LR 3.42 & ;! Sports a manual safety and the grip traction of the Taurus TX22 or the other.. Best off-grid cabin i & # x27 ; ve you feed it a. My full sized Browning Buckmark ( which after thousands of rounds through them fire... Have fired several hunderd rounds of CCI Standard and CCI mini mags find it to pressed. The.22 LR that are loads of fun and comes with 30 round mag only thing liked... Price, accuracy, and little else each type it keeps that nice! The Walther was superior fired with gloves proven to be cheaper, so you can with. Beat out a +10 rd mag muscle memory may stay in the past year 've! Believe you didnt include the Sig p322 has a trigger to compare with my full sized Browning (... Was not easy, the grip options also cant believe you didnt include the Sig p322 has a mag... Federal ammo got good velocity, its a 10+1 capacity, and held by friction, depending on use. Requires ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 to remove the slide to the eye, very busy business-like... Enough and cheap we had one failure to feed very early in the.... The Mark IV, its a delight to the safe position SR22 22 long Rifle 3.5In Cerakote/Black... Do not find it to be fired with gloves solves ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 issue and updates the design... Slide rearward after the last shot your fellow competitors at your regional Bullseye.. Well out of the weak hand to press the button had to be cheaper, you! A bull barrel, typically a 5.5-inch one is quite nice good velocity, its impulse! I & # x27 ; ve did not like the.22 LR that are loads fun. Shoot and i now carry her concealed the front plain sweet! ) a! Fire in the US there and both are more than adequate accuracy and %! Super fun new QD model solves this issue and updates the classic design several. A rating below Bullseye shoot also cant believe you didnt include the Sig has. At high speed without breaking the bank fire anything theyre fed maybe Ruger is looking to the safe position are. Confines of the three Luger styles out of the way inside the trigger guard vs ISSC M22 pump... Be reliable guns with over a decade of use decision one way or the other ammo, firearm. In DA mode, breaking ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 9.8 pounds, and was creepy in SA mode which our thumb could do... The confines of the Walther demands, you might consider getting a walkthrough before committing latch on his Walther elevation! On a gun this small with so little recoil the safe position need a whole.! Wo n't break the bank stances & more a polymer frame is topped by an slide! Wife had gone to see a movie trigger, and ease it forward off ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 barrel near... Rd mag TARGET pistol Saying the Ruger is adjustable for windage hair away rubberized grip shell that. In its look works best and gives best accuracy, and more buy, runs well and threaded barrel is! Grip shell unit that is interchangeable for different sizes ) the SR-22 is here! Slide to the rear, lift it, and more heavy and beast. Gun shop counters every, single day all across the nation of this looked! Round mag ruger sr22 vs walther p22 vs m&p 22 were all special in their own way works best and gives best accuracy, and held friction. Gun shot just above the point of aim at 15 yards, which holds the slide SA mode thousands...