Looking at the list top-to-bottom, we had to "seed" the entries. No surprise that Chris "Jesus" Ferguson was an almost unanimous #1. The surprise is that Dr. Pauly was the only person who didn't rank Ferguson in the top spot, instead opting for crazy-ass Finn Ilari "ziigmund" Sahamies.
Complete breakdown on the list and what everyone thought of the other guy's picks here.
And for the hell of it, one more use of quotation marks "here."